
Supplier Delivery Scorecard: Define OTIF Before Comparing Suppliers
A supplier delivery scorecard is a shared record of delivery commitments, actual receipts and exceptions. Its purpose is to support decisions about recurring delivery problems. Before ranking suppliers, procurement and warehouse teams need to agree what each measure counts and which records support it.
What does OTIF measure?
On-time in-full (OTIF) measures the share of eligible orders that meet both the agreed delivery timing and the full-quantity requirement. APQC’s order-based definition combines completeness with the agreed timeframe. The practical framework below adapts that idea to a buyer’s supplier-receipt review; it is a proposed working method, not a universal benchmark.
Check your system’s calculation before comparing reports. Infor’s supply chain performance documentation uses order lines and specific receipt or shipment statuses. A line-based result cannot be assumed equivalent to an order-based result. Keep the measurement unit and population visible beside the percentage.
Agree the measurement rules before the reporting period
| Rule | Decision to record | Suggested evidence owner |
|---|---|---|
| Unit | Whole purchase order or individual order line? Never mix them in one denominator. | Procurement analyst |
| Delivery commitment | Which agreed receipt date, delivery window and time zone apply? Retain the original and any approved revision. | Buyer |
| Receipt event | Use arrival/receipt evidence at the agreed location; a dispatch date alone does not prove arrival. | Receiving team |
| Full quantity | Define required quantity, unit of measure and how split receipts are combined before the deadline. | Buyer and receiving team |
| Population | Choose orders due in the period or orders received in the period; state the reporting cutoff and exclusions. | Report owner |
| Exceptions | Record buyer changes, cancellations and missing evidence separately, with an approval trail. | Buyer and supplier contact |
For a due-in-period scorecard, keep overdue orders in view even when nothing has arrived. Do not silently remove them by filtering only completed receipts. Publish the count of records with missing evidence and the treatment applied; incomplete data should not automatically become a successful delivery.
Hypothetical example: calculate the joint result
Illustrative example only — not HPA or client performance data. Assume ten purchase orders were due in one month, all were received by the reporting cutoff, and all have complete evidence. Assess each order against the same receipt window and quantity rule.
| Observed outcome | Orders |
|---|---|
| On time and in full | 7 |
| Late but in full | 2 |
| On time but incomplete | 1 |
| Total eligible orders | 10 |
OTIF = orders meeting both conditions ÷ eligible orders × 100 = 7 ÷ 10 × 100 = 70%. On-time performance is 80% and in-full performance is 90%. Averaging those two percentages to get 85% does not count the orders meeting both conditions. Multiplying them also does not recover the observed joint result.
The ten-order example demonstrates the calculation, not an acceptable target or a representative sample. Show the number of eligible orders beside each supplier’s result. Before ranking suppliers, check whether order complexity, delivery terms, reporting dates and data coverage are comparable.
Turn the scorecard into an action log
- Start with the missed commitments: purchase order, agreed receipt date, actual receipt, shortage and supporting evidence.
- Ask the supplier and internal owner to validate the exception before assigning a cause. A late receipt may involve transport, booking, internal receiving or a supplier issue.
- Assign one corrective action, one accountable person and a review date. Separate an immediate recovery action from a change intended to prevent recurrence.
- At the next review, check the agreed action and compare a consistently defined period. A higher percentage alone does not demonstrate that the action caused the change.
For the wider operating context, read supply chain management strategies and procurement management and cost control. Delivery reliability is one input to supplier management; it should sit alongside quality, commercial terms and operational risk.
Questions to resolve with your team
Does an early delivery count as on time?
Only if it falls within the agreed acceptance window. Write that rule down before scoring. An unwanted early receipt can create a storage or scheduling problem even when the final deadline has not passed.
Can several partial deliveries pass the in-full test?
Under the proposed order-based method, they can if the cumulative required quantity is received within the agreed window. If your contract or system uses a different rule, document it and apply it consistently.
What if the promised date changes?
Retain the original commitment, approved revision, reason and approval date. Report against the chosen rule transparently; repeatedly moving dates after a miss can hide the original service problem.
Build the skills behind reliable supplier reporting
Professionals exploring broader supply chain learning can review HPA’s CSCP course page and confirm current program details with the training team. For a team need, use HPA’s corporate training enquiry page to share the roles involved, participant numbers, current reporting challenge, preferred timing and intended learning outcomes. Do not include confidential supplier records in an initial enquiry.
Sources and scope
Primary references: APQC: orders delivered complete and on time and Infor: supply chain performance measures. Reviewed on 13 November 2026. The scorecard, role assignments and numerical example are editorial suggestions for discussion, not a prescribed standard, a case study or a promise of operational results.

